Who must report on internal financial controls, the Section 143(3)(i) exemption, internal audit under Section 138, and how to build a risk control matrix.
Internal financial controls (IFC) are the approvals, checks and reconciliations that stop errors and fraud before they reach the books. For a growing manufacturing company they also decide whether the statutory auditor can sign a clean report on controls, or has to point out weaknesses.
This guide explains which companies must report on IFC under the Companies Act, 2013, when internal audit becomes mandatory, and how to document controls in a Risk Control Matrix (RCM) that will stand up to testing.
What the Law Requires, and From Whom
The Act deals with IFC in three separate places. They are often confused, so it helps to keep them apart.
| Provision | Who it applies to | What is required |
|---|---|---|
| Section 134(5)(e) | Listed companies | Directors state that IFC were laid down, are adequate and were operating effectively |
| Rule 8(5)(viii), Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014 | Companies preparing a Board's report | Details of the adequacy of IFC with reference to the financial statements |
| Section 143(3)(i) | Statutory auditor of every company, unless exempt | Report whether the company has adequate IFC over financial reporting and whether they operated effectively |
The Act describes IFC broadly: policies and procedures for the orderly and efficient conduct of business, safeguarding of assets, prevention and detection of fraud and errors, accuracy and completeness of accounting records, and timely preparation of reliable financial information. The auditor's report under Section 143(3)(i) is narrower — it covers only controls over financial reporting.
The private company exemption from auditor's IFC reporting
Under MCA notification G.S.R. 583(E) dated 13 June 2017 (as corrected on 13 July 2017), the auditor's IFC reporting does not apply to a private company that is:
- a One Person Company or a small company; or
- a private company with turnover below ₹50 crore as per its latest audited financial statements and aggregate borrowings from banks, financial institutions or any body corporate below ₹25 crore at all times during the year.
Both conditions in the second limb must be met together. The exemption is also lost if the company has defaulted in filing its financial statements (Section 137) or annual return (Section 92) with the Registrar. A late AOC-4 or MGT-7 can therefore bring IFC reporting back into the audit.
The small company limits were raised from 1 December 2025 to paid-up capital not exceeding ₹10 crore and turnover not exceeding ₹100 crore (both conditions together; holding and subsidiary companies are excluded). Some companies that were outside the exemption last year may now be inside it — see the revised small company definition. Classification should be checked afresh every year.
When Internal Audit Is Mandatory — Section 138
Section 138, read with Rule 13 of the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, requires the following companies to appoint an internal auditor. The test is based on the preceding financial year, and any one condition is enough.
| Company type | Turnover | Borrowings from banks / PFIs (at any time) | Other tests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listed company | Always covered | — | — |
| Unlisted public company | ₹200 crore or more | ₹100 crore or more | Paid-up capital ₹50 crore or more; deposits ₹25 crore or more at any time |
| Private company | ₹200 crore or more | ₹100 crore or more | — |
Points to note:
- For FY 2026-27, the test uses FY 2025-26 figures.
- Borrowings that crossed the limit at any point in the year count, even if repaid by 31 March.
- The internal auditor may be a Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant, or another professional decided by the Board, and may or may not be an employee.
- Under Section 144, the statutory auditor cannot provide internal audit services to the same company.
Where CARO 2020 applies, the auditor also reports under Clause 3(xiv) whether the company has an internal audit system commensurate with its size and nature, and whether the internal audit reports were considered. CARO does not apply to small companies, OPCs, and private companies (not a holding or subsidiary of a public company) whose paid-up capital plus reserves, bank borrowings and total revenue stay within the ₹1 crore / ₹1 crore / ₹10 crore limits. A clause-wise view is in this CARO 2020 reporting guide.
Building the Risk Control Matrix
An RCM is a table that links each risk in a business process to the control that addresses it, the person responsible, how often it runs, and the evidence it leaves. Auditors test against this document, so it should describe what actually happens, not an ideal.
A typical row records:
- Process and sub-process (for example, Procure-to-Pay → vendor payment)
- Risk (payment to a fictitious or duplicate vendor)
- Control (payments released only against a three-way matched PO, GRN and invoice; vendor master changes approved by finance head)
- Type — preventive or detective; manual or system-enforced
- Frequency — per transaction, daily, monthly, quarterly
- Control owner and evidence (ERP approval log, signed reconciliation)
Core cycles for a manufacturing unit
| Cycle | Key risks | Typical controls |
|---|---|---|
| Procure-to-Pay | Ghost vendors, split POs to avoid approval limits, duplicate payments | Approval matrix by value; three-way match; duplicate checks on GSTIN and bank account in vendor master |
| Order-to-Cash | Unauthorised credit, unbilled dispatches, manual price overrides | System credit limits; dispatch only against invoice and e-way bill; reconcile dispatch register with GSTR-1; debtor confirmations |
| Inventory & production | Yield loss hiding unrecorded sales, scrap sold for cash, weighbridge overrides | Monthly yield against technical norms; numbered gate passes; ERP-linked weighbridge with no manual entry; periodic physical counts |
| Payroll | Ghost employees, wrong overtime, PF/ESIC lapses | Biometric attendance linked to payroll; HR approval for new joiners; monthly PF/ESIC reconciliation |
| Fixed assets | Unrecorded disposals, wrong capitalisation | Tagged fixed asset register; periodic physical verification; capex approvals |
| Financial close | Unapproved journals, unreconciled balances | Journal approval; monthly bank reconciliation by someone who does not handle cash; GST-to-books reconciliation |
Delegation of authority and segregation of duties
Two supporting documents make the RCM workable:
- Delegation of authority (DOA) matrix — who can approve purchases, payments, discounts, credit periods and scrap sales, and up to what value. Limits should be set by the Board to suit the company's size.
- Segregation of duties — authorisation, custody of assets, recording and reconciliation should sit with different people. A common gap in smaller units is one person who selects the supplier, receives the goods and approves the invoice.
Where the books are kept in Tally, Busy, SAP or similar software, the audit trail (edit log) required under Rule 3(1) of the Companies (Accounts) Rules since 1 April 2023 is itself an IT control the auditor examines. See audit trail compliance in accounting software.
Testing Design and Operating Effectiveness
The ICAI Guidance Note on Audit of Internal Financial Controls over Financial Reporting frames testing in two parts:
- Design effectiveness — is the control, as described, capable of preventing or detecting a material error? An approval limit that can be bypassed by splitting a bill fails design even if staff follow it.
- Operating effectiveness — did the control work consistently through the whole year, with evidence? Controls applied only near year-end fail this test.
The usual steps are:
- Walkthrough — trace one or two transactions end to end to confirm the documented control is how the process actually runs.
- Sample testing — pick samples spread across the year and check that approvals, matches and reviews happened each time.
- Re-performance — for key controls, redo the reconciliation or calculation independently.
Classifying Deficiencies
| Level | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Deficiency | A control is missing or does not operate as designed, so misstatements may not be prevented or detected on time |
| Significant deficiency | Less severe than a material weakness, but important enough to merit the attention of those charged with governance |
| Material weakness | A reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented or detected on a timely basis |
A material weakness leads to a modified opinion on IFC in the auditor's report. Significant deficiencies are communicated in writing to those charged with governance.
A hypothetical example
Suppose a private company manufacturing steel fabrication products has turnover of ₹120 crore and bank borrowings of ₹30 crore. It is not a small company (turnover exceeds ₹100 crore) and does not meet the ₹50 crore / ₹25 crore exemption, so its auditor must report on IFC. It is below the Section 138 limits, so internal audit is not mandatory.
During testing, the auditor finds that the purchase officer can edit vendor bank details in the ERP without approval, and no one reviews the change log. Payments are still three-way matched, so the risk of paying for goods not received is controlled, but the risk of diverting a genuine payment is not. Depending on the amounts involved and any compensating controls (such as a monthly review of vendor master changes), this may be classed as a significant deficiency or a material weakness. The fix — restricting master-data edits to the finance team with maker-checker approval — is simple, but only if it is in place well before year-end so it can be shown to have operated.
Common Mistakes
- Assuming the exemption without checking. Turnover and borrowings must both be below the limits, and a single late ROC filing removes the exemption. Keep AOC-4 and MGT-7 filings on time.
- Copying a generic RCM. A template that does not match the company's real process fails at the walkthrough stage.
- No evidence of review. A reconciliation that is prepared but not signed or approved in the system cannot be shown to have operated.
- Year-end remediation. A control introduced in March cannot demonstrate operating effectiveness for the year.
- Ignoring IT controls. User access rights, password sharing and a disabled audit trail undermine every system-based control.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every private company need an IFC report from its auditor? No. OPCs, small companies, and private companies with turnover below ₹50 crore and borrowings below ₹25 crore are exempt, provided they have no default in filing financial statements or annual returns.
Can the statutory auditor prepare the company's RCM? Section 144 bars the statutory auditor from internal audit and certain other services to the same company. Management should own the RCM; the auditor evaluates it.
How often should key controls be tested internally? There is no fixed rule, but quarterly testing of key controls lets gaps be fixed while there is still time to show the control operating before year-end.
This guide reflects the Companies Act, 2013, the Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014, the MCA exemption notifications and the small company thresholds as they stand in November 2026. Thresholds and exemptions are amended from time to time; confirm the current position for your company before relying on these figures.
Related Advisory Services & Practice Guides
- Information on internal audit for companies in Chhattisgarh and Odisha.
- Information on statutory audit for private limited companies.
- Assistance with ROC annual compliance filing.
- Background reading: Statutory audit checklist for private limited companies.
Calculate Your Exact Tax Liability (Old vs New Regime)
Compare the ₹75,000 standard deduction, ₹12.75L zero-tax threshold, and Chapter VI-A deductions for your exact income.
Need Direct CA Consultation in Raipur?
Connect with our partner-led practice at GF-28, Shyam Plaza, Pandri, Raipurfor GST advisory, Income Tax audit (Sec 44AB), Bank DPR & CMA Data, Company Registration, and Chhattisgarh Industrial Subsidies.
Authored by CA Rabi Agrawal & Practice Team
Rabi Agrawal & Associates, Chartered Accountants — Head Office Raipur (CG), Branch Office Jayapatna (Odisha).

