Income Tax Notice Guide: Sec 142(1), 143(2) & 148 Responses

Receiving an Income Tax notice on your registered email address or discovering an alert under the "Pending Actions" tab of the e-filing portal can be an intimidating experience. In our practice at Rabi Agrawal & Associates across Raipur and Kalahandi, we routinely observe business owners, individual taxpayers, and finance heads panic when a notice arrives. However, in the current landscape of digitized administration and faceless assessments, an Income Tax notice is often a automated administrative communication seeking clarification, data reconciliation, or additional documentation.

The transition from traditional territorial assessment to the National Faceless Assessment Centre (NFAC) under Section 144B has fundamentally changed how tax notices are issued and answered. Today, the Income Tax Department relies heavily on big-data analytics through the Insight Portal, matching your filed Income Tax Return (ITR) against third-party information collected via Statement of Financial Transactions (SFT), Form 26AS, Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) filings, and the Annual Information Statement (AIS).

Ignoring a notice or filing a hasty, unstructured response without documentary evidence can trigger severe adverse consequences—ranging from penalty proceedings to ex-parte Best Judgment Assessment under Section 144. This practical advisory guide provides a practical, ground-level blueprint for identifying, evaluating, and responding to key Income Tax notices.

---

Master Comparison Table: Types of Income Tax Notices, Statutory Limits & Action Plan

To help taxpayers and finance teams quickly identify their compliance obligations, the table below outlines the six core notices issued by the Income Tax Department, their underlying causes, statutory response windows, and recommended action steps.

---

Process Matrix: Income Tax Notice Handling & Response Protocol

When an Income Tax notice lands in your inbox, follow this structured step-by-step decision matrix to ensure full legal and procedural compliance before submitting your response:

---

Deep-Dive Analysis: Understanding the 6 Core Income Tax Notices

1. Section 139(9): Defective Return Notice

A notice under Section 139(9) is issued when the CPC processing engine identifies an omission or structural inconsistency in your filed return that renders it incomplete.

Common Triggers:

• Unpaid Tax: Claiming self-assessment tax in the return without actually paying it via Challan 280/CRN.
• Missing Tax Audit Report: Declaring gross business turnover exceeding ₹2 Crore (or ₹10 Crore under cash transaction limits) without uploading the Tax Audit Report in Form 3B/3CA-3CD u/s 44AB.
• Turnover Mismatch: Inconsistency between the Gross Receipts declared in the Profit & Loss Account and the turnover disclosed in the ITR schedules.
• Missing Balance Sheet Details: Regular business return filed under ITR-3 or ITR-4 without filling key financial parameters like Sundry Debtors, Sundry Creditors, Stock-in-Trade, and Cash-in-Hand.

How to Respond:

You have 15 days from the receipt of the notice to rectify the defect. Log into the e-filing portal, navigate to Pending Actions ➔ Response to Defective Return, select the notice, and upload a fresh return JSON file rectifying the error. If additional time is required (e.g., waiting for an auditor's report), submit an online adjournment request before the 15-day window expires.

---

2. Section 143(1): Intimation & Prima Facie Adjustments

Upon filing your ITR, the CPC processes the return electronically and issues an Intimation under Section 143(1). This is a comparative document presenting two distinct columns: As Provided by Taxpayer versus As Computed under Section 143(1).

Understanding Proposed Adjustments u/s 143(1)(a):

Before issuing a final tax demand intimation, the department issues a communication proposing "prima facie adjustments" under Section 143(1)(a) for:

1. Mathematical Errors: Arithmetical mistakes in tax computation or rebate calculation.
2. Incorrect Claims: Claiming deductions under Chapter VI-A (such as Section 80C, 80D, 80G) that are not supported by Form 16 or Part B of Form 26AS.
3. TDS Mismatches: Differences between TDS claimed in the return and TDS reflected on the TRACES portal (Form 26AS).
4. Unreported AIS/TIS Income: Omission of savings bank interest, fixed deposit interest, mutual fund dividend, or share transaction gains captured in your AIS.

Ground Reality for Civil Contractors & MSMEs: PWD civil contractors in Chhattisgarh and Odisha frequently receive 143(1)(a) adjustment notices due to gross receipt mismatches. Government departments deduct TDS under Section 194C on contract payments. If the contractor reports revenue on a percentage-of-completion basis or net of mobilization advance, the CPC flags the difference between Form 26AS receipts and ITR revenue as undisclosed income. Resolving this requires submitting a structured reconciliation statement showing year-wise revenue recognition.

Response Protocol:

Taxpayers are granted 30 days to respond to a Section 143(1)(a) communication online. You can select "Agree" for valid discrepancies (which updates the tax computation) or "Disagree" for incorrect adjustments, uploading proof such as TDS certificates, bank statements, or Chapter VI-A investment receipts. If a final demand intimation has already been passed, file a Rectification Application under Section 154.

---

3. Section 142(1): Inquiry Notice Before Assessment

Section 142(1) empowers the Assessing Officer (AO) or the National Faceless Assessment Centre (NFAC) to issue a formal inquiry notice calling upon the taxpayer to:

1. File an Income Tax Return if it has not been filed within the due date.
2. Produce books of accounts, ledgers, bills, and purchase vouchers.
3. Provide a written statement of assets and liabilities (including bank accounts, immovable properties, and investments).

Ground Reality in Faceless Questionnaire Notices:

Under the Faceless Assessment framework, a notice under Section 142(1) comes accompanied by a detailed Annexure Questionnaire containing 10 to 20 specific queries. For instance, a steel rerolling mill operating in Urla or Bhanpuri (Raipur) receiving a Section 142(1) notice might be asked to furnish:

• Month-wise raw material (billets/ingots) consumption vs finished goods yield ratio.
• Complete name, address, PAN, and bank statements of unsecured loan providers under Section 68.
• GST Return (GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B) reconciliations against ITR turnover.

Penalty Consequences of Non-Compliance:

Failing to comply with a Section 142(1) notice carries severe legal risks:

• Statutory Penalty: Levy of ₹10,000 for each default under Section 272A(1)(d).
• Ex-Parte Assessment: Immediate issuance of a Show Cause Notice for passing a Best Judgment Assessment under Section 144.

---

4. Section 143(2): Scrutiny Notice (Faceless Assessment Scheme u/s 144B)

A notice under Section 143(2) signifies that your return has been selected for detailed audit and scrutiny. The issuance of this notice establishes statutory jurisdiction over your assessment.

Statutory Limitation Period:

Under the amended provisions of the Income Tax Act, a notice under Section 143(2) cannot be served after the expiry of three months from the end of the Financial Year in which the return was filed. For example, for an ITR filed for AY 2025-26 on July 31, 2025, the notice must be served on or before June 30, 2026. Any notice served after this statutory deadline is legally invalid for lack of jurisdiction.

Categories of Scrutiny Assessment:

1. Limited Scrutiny: Focused strictly on pre-defined parameters flagged by computer algorithms (e.g., sudden drop in gross profit ratio, high cash deposits during demonetization/festive season, or major property purchase).
2. Complete Scrutiny: Full-scale audit of all business operations, books of accounts, personal bank statements, and tax positions.
3. Compulsory Scrutiny: Triggered automatically in cases involving search and seizure (Section 132), survey operations (Section 133A), or recurring legal additions from previous years.

The Faceless Assessment Workflow:

Under Section 144B, scrutiny assessments are assigned randomly to Assessment Units (AU) across India. The AU evaluates digital submissions, supported by Verification Units (VU) for field inquiries and Technical Units (TU) for legal guidance. If the AU proposes an addition, it issues a Draft Assessment Order (DAO). The taxpayer gets a final opportunity to submit objections before the Final Assessment Order (FAO) is passed.

---

5. Section 148 & 148A: Income Escaping Assessment (Reopening Past Years)

Reopening past assessments under Section 148 is one of the most litigated areas of direct tax law. Following the landmark overhaul in Finance Act 2021, the department must adhere to a strict statutory procedure before reopening an assessment:

Statutory Time Limits for Reopening:

• Normal Cases: Up to 3 years from the end of the relevant Assessment Year.
• Extended Window (High-Value Evasion): Up to 10 years from the end of the relevant Assessment Year, provided the Assessing Officer possesses evidence that income escaping tax—represented in the form of asset, expenditure, or book entry—amounts to or is likely to amount to ₹50 Lakhs or more for that year.

Real-World Ground Scenario: Real Estate & Joint Development Agreements

In rapidly expanding real estate hubs like Raipur, Durg, and Kalahandi, land buyers and real estate developers frequently face Section 148 notices. For example, a landowner in Civil Lines, Raipur entered into a Joint Development Agreement (JDA) with a developer. The stamp duty valuation of the developer's share was ₹1.20 Crore, but the owner failed to declare capital gains under Section 45(5A) in that specific Assessment Year. Three years later, the Insight Portal flagged the unregistered/registered transaction, triggering a Section 148A(b) show-cause notice. Handling such cases requires examining whether the stamp duty valuation correctly reflects market value, verifying possession transfer dates, and challenging procedural flaws in the Section 148A approval chain.

---

6. Section 245: Adjustment of Refund Against Outstanding Tax Demand

Section 245 is a statutory notification informing you that the department intends to set off your current year's approved tax refund against an outstanding tax demand from a previous assessment year.

Response Protocol:

The department provides a mandatory 30-day notice period. Taxpayers must log into the e-filing portal under Pending Actions ➔ Response to Outstanding Demand. You have three response options:

1. Demand is Correct: The system adjusts the refund against the demand, and any remaining balance refund is credited to your bank account.
2. Demand is Partially Correct: Accept the undisputed portion and submit documentary evidence for the disputed balance.
3. Disagree with Demand: Select this option if the past demand is completely erroneous (e.g., tax was already paid via Challan 280, credit for TDS was ignored, or an appeal is currently pending before the CIT(Appeals) with a stay order). Upload copy of payment challans, past ITRs, or appeal filing acknowledgments (Form 35).

---

Step-by-Step e-Filing Portal Compliance Protocol

When submitting responses under the Income Tax e-Proceeding module, strictly adhere to the following procedural workflow:

Step 1: Verify the Document Identification Number (DIN)

Under CBDT Circular No. 19/2019, any notice, order, or letter issued by the Income Tax Department without a valid, system-generated Document Identification Number (DIN) is invalid, void ab initio, and non-est in the eyes of law.

• Go to the official e-filing portal (incometax.gov.in`).
• Under Quick Links, click Authenticate Notice/Order Issued by ITD.
• Search using the DIN provided in the top header of your notice. If the system returns "No record found", consult a tax advocate to draft a jurisdictional challenge.

Step 2: Download Your Comprehensive Data Trail

Before typing a single line of your response, download and cross-examine:

1. Annual Information Statement (AIS) & Taxpayer Information Summary (TIS) for the relevant AY.
2. Form 26AS from the TRACES portal to verify TDS/TCS credits and advance tax payments.
3. Computation of Income & Audit Report filed for that Assessment Year.

Step 3: Access the e-Proceedings Dashboard

1. Log into your account on incometax.gov.in.
2. Click on Pending Actions ➔ e-Proceedings.
3. Locate the notice under the active proceedings list and click View Notices/Orders.
4. Click Submit Response against the specific letter or inquiry notice.

Step 4: Formatting PDF Attachments and Upload Requirements

• File Size & Format: Attachments must be in PDF format. Each file size must not exceed 5MB.
• Index & Page Numbering: For voluminous submissions, create a clear Master Index on Page 1, listing all attached annexures (e.g., Annexure A: Bank Reconciliation, Annexure B: Purchase Ledgers).
• Document Clarity: Ensure scans are clean, legible, and unmasked. Scanned copies of unreadable receipts often lead to disallowance by Assessment Units.

---

Submitting Written Submissions & Building an Unassailable Audit Trail

In a faceless assessment environment, your written submission is your sole voice. The Assessment Unit evaluates your case entirely on the clarity, structure, and documentary proof attached to your reply.

Recommended Structure of a Professional Written Reply:

1. Header & Subject: Reference the Notice DIN, Section, Assessment Year, and Notice Date prominently.
2. Procedural Background: Briefly state the filing date of the original return, income declared, and notice details.
3. Point-by-Point Rebuttal: Address each query in the AO's questionnaire systematically. Avoid vague general statements; quote specific figures, ledger page numbers, and dates.
4. Documentary Evidence: Support every assertion with primary records (bank reconciliation statements, cash flow statements, party ledgers, tax invoices, and transport bills).
5. Legal Precedents: Quote relevant decisions of the Supreme Court, High Courts, or Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) where interpretation of law is involved.

Ground Examples from Regional Industries:

A. Rice Millers in Kalahandi & Jayapatna (Paddy & CMR Receipts Reconciliation)

Rice millers executing Custom Milling Rice (CMR) contracts for the Odisha State Civil Supplies Corporation (OSCSC) frequently face Section 143(1) and 142(1) notices regarding revenue mismatches. The portal flags discrepancies between Mandi fee receipts, OSCSC milling charges, and TDS deducted under Section 194C.

• The Defense: Prepare a comprehensive quantitative reconciliation statement matching paddy received from Mandi, out-turn ratio of CMR rice, gunny bag sales, and milling charge bills against Form 26AS.

B. Steel Rerolling Mills in Urla & Bhanpuri, Raipur (Section 68 Unsecured Loans)

Steel manufacturing units borrowing working capital from private entities often face scrutiny u/s 143(2) regarding cash credits u/s 68.

• The Defense: To discharge the statutory onus under Section 68, the taxpayer must establish three cumulative limbs: Identity of Creditor, Creditworthiness, and Genuineness of Transaction. Submit the lender’s PAN, ITR acknowledgment, audited balance sheet demonstrating net worth, bank statement highlighting the loan disbursement via banking channels, and loan agreement copy.

---

Avoiding Default Assessment u/s 144 (Best Judgment Assessment)

Section 144 mandates the Assessing Officer to pass an ex-parte assessment order to the best of their judgment when the taxpayer:

• Fails to file a return required u/s 139(4) or 139(5).
• Fails to comply with all terms of a Section 142(1) inquiry notice.
• Fails to comply with a direction to get accounts audited under Section 142(2A).
• Fails to respond to a Section 143(2) scrutiny notice.

How to Prevent Section 144 Ex-Parte Orders:

1. Never Allow a Deadline to Expire: If compiling documents (e.g., historic bank statements or party balance confirmations) requires time, log into e-Proceedings and click Seek Adjournment before the deadline passes.
2. Submit Interim Replies: If you have gathered 70% of the requested information, upload an interim response submitting the available documents while formally requesting a 10-day extension for the remainder. This establishes bona fide compliance on record.

---

Post-Assessment Legal Remedies

If an adverse assessment order or rectified demand is passed despite your submissions, you have three primary legal remedies under the Income Tax Act:

1. Rectification Application under Section 154

Applicable when there is a clear mistake apparent from the record (e.g., mathematical error, failure to give credit for advance tax or TDS paid, or incorrect adoption of tax rates). Rectification applications must be filed online within 4 years from the end of the financial year in which the order was passed.

2. Appeal to CIT(Appeals) / NFAC under Section 246A

If the Assessing Officer makes illegal additions or disallowances, file an online appeal in Form 35 before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) within 30 days of service of the assessment order and demand notice.

• Mandatory Deposit: To seek a stay of demand during the appeal, the taxpayer must pay 20% of the disputed tax demand under Section 220(6) or file a formal stay petition detailing financial hardship.

3. Revision Petition under Section 264

Where an order is adverse and the time limit for filing an appeal has expired (or the right to appeal is waived), a taxpayer can file a Revision Petition before the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) within 1 year from the date of service of the order.

---

Professional Assistance & Direct Tax Practice

Handling Income Tax notices requires a rare blend of deep statutory knowledge, procedural precision, and ground-level accounting insight. A single misstatement in an online reply can be construed as an admission of liability by Assessment Units.

At Rabi Agrawal & Associates, our direct tax litigation team regularly represents business entities, industrial units, real estate developers, and high-net-worth individuals across Raipur, Bhilai, Urla, Kalahandi, and Jayapatna. We assist clients in:

• Conducting thorough tax risk audits and AIS/26AS reconciliations.
• Drafting unassailable written submissions for Section 142(1), 143(2), and 148 notices.
• Formulating defenses against Section 144 ex-parte show-cause notices.
• Representing taxpayers in Faceless Assessment proceedings and drafting CIT(Appeals) petitions in Form 35.

Facing an Income Tax notice or upcoming e-Proceeding deadline? Reach out to our direct tax practice team at Rabi Agrawal & Associates to review your notice and file a precise, legally robust response on the e-filing portal before your statutory window closes.

---

Related Advisory Services & Practice Guides

• Access expert statutory assistance for Income tax notices & appeals consultation with our senior Chartered Accountants.
• Access expert statutory assistance for Tax audit consultation with our senior Chartered Accountants.