Analysis of statutory provisions surrounding fraudulent ITC claims without underlying supply of goods, Section 83 provisional bank attachment, and criminal defense strategies.
"Fake invoicing" under GST refers to the issuance of a tax invoice for a supply of goods or services that never actually took place, purely to enable the recipient to claim Input Tax Credit (ITC) that has no genuine underlying transaction behind it. "Circular trading" is a related pattern — a chain of paper-only invoices between a set of entities (sometimes controlled by the same person or connected group) that inflates turnover and passes ITC around the circle without a single unit of real goods moving. Both are treated as some of the most serious offences under the CGST Act, 2017, and are the primary target of the department's data-analytics-driven scrutiny of GSTR-2B mismatches.
1. The Statutory Offence: Section 132
Section 132(1) of the CGST Act lists specific acts as offences, several of which are directly implicated in fake invoicing:
| Clause | Offence | Cognizable & non-bailable under Section 132(5)? |
|---|---|---|
| 132(1)(b) | Issues any invoice without actual supply of goods/services, leading to wrongful availment or utilisation of ITC or refund | Yes, where the ITC or refund involved exceeds ₹5 crore |
| 132(1)(c) | Avails ITC using an invoice referred to in clause (b) | Yes, where the ITC exceeds ₹5 crore |
| 132(1)(a) | Supplies goods/services without any invoice, with intent to evade tax | Yes, where the tax evaded exceeds ₹5 crore |
| 132(1)(f) | Falsifies or substitutes financial records or produces fake accounts/documents | No. Punishable with up to six months' imprisonment or fine or both, and non-cognizable and bailable |
Where the amount involved exceeds ₹5 crore in an offence under clause (a), (b), (c) or (d), the offence is cognizable and non-bailable under Section 132(5), and the punishment is imprisonment of up to five years with fine. A GST officer authorised under Section 69 can then arrest without a warrant, and bail is not a matter of right but must be argued before a Magistrate or, on appeal, before the Sessions Court/High Court. For ₹2 crore to ₹5 crore the imprisonment can extend to three years, and for ₹1 crore to ₹2 crore to one year, but these offences are non-cognizable and bailable. The department can still pursue civil penalty proceedings and provisional attachment in every case, and prosecution needs the previous sanction of the Commissioner under Section 132(6). Compounding is dealt with in GST compounding, offences and prosecution under Section 132.
2. Section 83 — Provisional Attachment of Property
Independent of any criminal proceeding, the Commissioner may invoke Section 83 to provisionally attach any property, including bank accounts, of the taxable person (or a person named in Section 122(1A)) after the initiation of any proceeding under Chapter XII (assessment), Chapter XIV (inspection, search, seizure and arrest) or Chapter XV (demands and recovery), if the Commissioner is of the opinion that attachment is necessary to protect the interest of revenue. This is the wording since 1 January 2022; the earlier list of specific sections (62, 63, 64, 67, 73 and 74) no longer applies. The procedure is in Rule 159.
Key points on provisional attachment relevant to a fake-invoicing case:
- The attachment order (Form GST DRC-22) must be issued in writing and ceases to have effect after one year from the date of the order, unless renewed by a fresh reasoned order.
- The taxpayer can file an objection in Form GST DRC-22A before the Commissioner under Rule 159(5), with restoration ordered in Form GST DRC-23 (from 1 November 2026 a rejection is recorded in Part B of Form DRC-22, under Notification No. 05/2026-Central Tax). Alternatively, the taxpayer can approach the jurisdictional High Court by writ petition, arguing that the attachment is disproportionate, mechanical, or not backed by tangible material. In Radha Krishan Industries (2021), the Supreme Court held that the Section 83 power must be exercised with extreme caution and only as a last resort to protect revenue, not as a punitive measure.
- Attachment of a current bank account used for day-to-day business (as opposed to a term deposit or non-operational account) is frequently challenged as disproportionate where it effectively shuts down a going concern before guilt is established.
3. How Fake Invoicing Cases Are Typically Detected
- GSTR-2B vs GSTR-3B/GSTR-1 mismatch analytics flag suppliers whose outward supply pattern shows no corresponding e-way bill generation for the declared turnover — a hallmark of paper-only billing.
- E-way bill data cross-verification against vehicle registration and toll/FASTag records exposes invoices with no genuine movement of goods.
- Common address/director/bank-account clusters across multiple GSTINs are flagged by the department's risk-rating engine as likely circular trading rings.
- Sudden turnover spikes in newly registered GSTINs with minimal fixed assets, no employees on EPFO records, and disproportionately high ITC claims relative to declared business scale.
4. Practical Defense Strategy
- Establish Genuine Movement of Goods: The single strongest defense is documentary proof of actual physical movement — valid e-way bills, weighbridge slips, transporter GRs/LRs, godown entry/exit registers, and payment through banking channels matching invoice value and timing.
- Demonstrate Bona Fide Purchaser Status: Where the taxpayer is a recipient accused of availing ITC on invoices later found to be issued by a non-existent or bogus supplier, the defense turns on showing the taxpayer exercised reasonable due diligence at the time of transaction — GSTIN verification, valid e-way bills, and banking-channel payment — even if the supplier is later found non-genuine. Courts have distinguished between a taxpayer who was defrauded by a bogus supplier and one who was knowingly complicit.
- Challenge Attachment Proportionality: File the Form DRC-22A objection promptly, and if unsuccessful, move the High Court under Article 226 citing the one-year limit under Section 83(2) and the requirement of a reasoned, non-mechanical order.
- Bail Application Strategy: For arrests under Section 132(5), bail applications emphasize cooperation with investigation, absence of flight risk, and — critically — that liability, if any, is a matter for adjudication under Section 74 or 74A (civil demand) rather than pre-judged through criminal prosecution before assessment is complete.
- Parallel Civil Defense under Section 74 or 74A: Simultaneously respond to the Show Cause Notice on the tax/ITC demand itself (Section 74 for fraud-related demands up to FY 2023-24, Section 74A from FY 2024-25 onwards) — a favorable or partially favorable adjudication order significantly strengthens the position in any parallel criminal proceeding.
Note: A genuine business can be drawn into a fake-invoicing inquiry because a vendor turned out to be non-existent, a recurring risk for MSMEs sourcing from unfamiliar suppliers. It should not be treated as routine paperwork. Reconstructing the transaction trail early, before the department's own timeline forces a rushed response, helps the reply. Related reading: summons and statement recording under Section 70, search, seizure and inspection under Section 67 and ITC reconciliation under Rule 36(4) and GSTR-2B.
Related Advisory Services & Practice Guides
- Service page: GST advisory & compliance
- Service page: GST notices & appeals
Calculate Your Exact Tax Liability (Old vs New Regime)
Compare the ₹75,000 standard deduction, ₹12.75L zero-tax threshold, and Chapter VI-A deductions for your exact income.
Need Direct CA Consultation in Raipur?
Connect with our partner-led practice at GF-28, Shyam Plaza, Pandri, Raipurfor GST advisory, Income Tax audit (Sec 44AB), Bank DPR & CMA Data, Company Registration, and Chhattisgarh Industrial Subsidies.
Authored by CA Rabi Agrawal & Practice Team
Rabi Agrawal & Associates, Chartered Accountants — Head Office Raipur (CG), Branch Office Jayapatna (Odisha).

